Coda, our dog was killed and at the time I’d been unpicking my mother’s dressing-gown. I received a phone call from a woman letting me know that she had Coda and she’d been struck by a car. I went into mourning for several days and didn’t feel like doing anything, particularly that which had consumed me that morning. In the scheme of things, it didn’t seem important. During loss, most things do not seem to have meaning. Of course, I knew that creating would pick me up but I couldn’t be bothered. I preferred to mope and some would say even indulge the hurt I felt for losing Coda. I couldn’t get over how she was full of life one minute and not the next. She looked peaceful lying in the back of the car after my partner picked her up from where he believed two women had dragged her after she was struck.
The driver of the car that killed her didn’t stop. But it must have been a shock when life was wrenched from Coda. We went through all the what ifs – what if I’d been gardening that morning she would have to have passed me on her ‘flight’ towards the back lane and then the main road and she may have been distracted from her purpose by seeing me. What if Philip hadn’t left the gate open because he was preoccupied with covering up a hole that Coda had dug under a wire fence? We realized however that if not now well – then another day…It was something that was bound to happen because Coda liked to run and visit her doggie friends up and down the lane. I nursed guilt as well, that instead of being absorbed in my creative pursuits, perhaps I should have given her more attention. What made Coda the sort of dog unable to sit quietly at my feet, happy to be near? A sort of creator’s or philosopher's dog – happy to ‘think’ and dream alongside me? According to a Kato Indian Creation story when God went forth to create the world, he took his dog with him. As I want to do when I go forth to create (not the world) but some felt, or indeed, to muse or write.
I perked up when we decided to get another dog to fill the hole in my heart and the void in our house. So I went back to unpicking those used dresses and the reflection that it brought. It may seem that Coda as a dog is replaceable and that the thought of a new dog brought relief from my grief. I am rushing to replace her and it's related, however, to my incapacity to be with ‘the hole in my heart’, which makes me want to rush and fill it with something, rather than attend to the pain. That sort of inability to deal with pain and loss, which caused me to happily have a pet rock for almost a decade, before I could consider having an intimate relationship with a man or indeed, a dog. Granted I was doing it rather backwards on the way towards intimacy (the man and then the dog but if you consider the dog like a child and we its parents, I've got it right)...
I miss Coda and I swear I can hear her barking in the yard (while it may only be the wind in the sails that provide shade at the front of the house). There are so many butterflies in the garden that I associate with Coda’s ‘soul’. Whenever I sight them, they make me feel light. We as humans tend to attribute ‘minds’ to animals because we have minds. (What minds are exactly is complex, and I may leave that to another post.) I purchase the book The Philosopher’s Dog by Raimond Gaita, hoping to find out something about the minds of dogs, indeed what Coda may have been thinking about when she flopped on the mat at the front door and heaved a huge sigh. Those sighs my mother reminded me as a young girl, ‘are for the desires of the heart that are unfulfilled.’
|Seeking out the chickens|
|Is she thinking, caught in reverie?|
While I don’t think that dogs ‘think’ or examine experiences as we do, searching for meaning, they must have ‘minds’. What made her cower when she messed the floor ‘thinking’ that as her previous ‘master’, I would strike her? What made her seem depressed after she’d been to the dog park? She wasn’t allowed off her lead to socialize with the other dogs, as it had been her first time. Was that the reason? Was she reminded of doggie fun and mischief with Tank? Usually full of zest, she moped for several hours. She was on the mat beside me for once (not as I created but as I ironed) and it seemed for the wrong reason. Not to be with me, but because something else preoccupied her and she was down. Some people would think I’m batty attributing a ‘mind’ that can reflect to a dog. She seemed as an individual sentient being, and one that could seek out the individual company of humans, other four-legged creatures or even the feathered two legged kind in chickens – the same individual that I fell in love with at first sight. Never mind that she had four legs, she had beautiful kohl rimmed eyes and a great smile. She could ring a bell when she needed to go outside (to the toilet) and she rang the bell to let me know that the cockatoo was eating from the bird feed. (We don’t like cockatoos eating from our bird feeder because when there’s no birdseed they can revert to eating the timber on your house.) What other evidence did I need to suspect that Coda had a mind? She could learn. She had memories. I'm sure she dreamed because I watched as she seemed to have a nightmare once, quivering, and (did I imagine) rapid eye movement…
Did I learn anything about a dog’s mind reading Gaita’s The Philosopher’s Dog? Well, Gaita would assign sentimentality to my way of thinking. Very simplistically, because dogs don’t reflect on the nature of death, in the way that humans do, acutely aware of their mortality, they don’t have a mind. Yet Gaita seems to contradict himself when he recounts the anecdote of the aged Gypsy (his dog) slinking past a gate behind which a younger and rather neurotic border collie waits; and the sidelong glance Gypsy gives, which seems to express her humiliation at being old. Gaita is tempted to say that his dog’s demeanour expressed an awareness of their common mortality. But he’s sure she does not know that she will die. I agree that young dogs are too busy living in the moment to contemplate death, just as young human beings don't reflect on death or feel their mortality. I’m sure that when Coda went through the gate and towards the garden and running down the lane towards the main road that death was most further from her mind, as it was from mine. While Philip expected it, I did not. I liked Coda running and exploring, free as butterflies, and I did not expect her to be stopped dead in her tracks. We were both naïve.
(The Kato Creation Myth is recounted in Raimond Gaita, The Philosopher’s Dog, Text Publishing, 2005)